Back to blog

SB 574 Sets Generative AI Rules for Attorneys and Arbitrators

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools have been adopted quickly and widely by businesses worldwide, including legal practitioners. It is not uncommon for attorneys to use AI tools for routine tasks, such as proofreading letters to clients and opposing counsel, as well as more complicated tasks, such as preparing petitions and appellate briefs.

For attorneys, the use of AI created novel professional responsibility challenges. Generative AI systems produce text, citations and legal analysis by modeling patterns from training data. They are capable of generating content that appears authoritative but is fabricated, a phenomenon widely referred to as "hallucination." At the same time, there were concerns that arbitration service providers were using AI tools capable of generating arbitration awards, which raised distinct concerns about the integrity of the decision process in private dispute resolution.

On Sept. 30, 2026, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill 574 (SB 574). He described it as a first-in-the-nation bill governing the use of generative AI by attorneys, arbitrators and alternative dispute resolution (ADR) providers.[1] It amends the Business and Professions Code (BPC) and the Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) to codify specific duties and prohibitions applicable to legal practitioners who use generative AI in the course of their professional responsibilities. The requirements of SB 574 go into effect on Jan. 1, 2027.

BACKGROUND

Prior to SB 574, California courts, including the workers' compensation appeals board (WCAB), used existing rules to impose sanctions on attorneys who submitted AI-generated citations to nonexistent cases without verification. (See, for example, Lopez Mendoza v. SWI Finishing, Inc., 2026 Cal. Wrk. Comp. P.D. LEXIS 160.) Also, California Rules of Court Standard 10.80 was adopted to address AI use by judicial officers.[2]

The legislative history for SB 574 specifically references Noland v. Land of the Free (2025) 114 Cal. App. 5th 426, in which the Court of Appeal fined an attorney $10,000 for filing an appellate brief containing fabricated quotations generated by ChatGPT. The court published the opinion as a warning to the legal community and stated: "Simply stated, no brief, pleading, motion, or any other paper filed in any court should contain any citations — whether provided by generative AI or any other source — that the attorney responsible for submitting the pleading has not personally read and verified."

The legislative history notes that SB 574 "seeks to provide basic guidelines for the use of generative AI by attorneys, judges, arbitrators and mediators by modeling some of its provisions off the California Rules of Court Standard 10.80 and the ruling in Noland regarding verifying cases and citations used in documents submitted to the courts." (Sen. Rules Com., Off. of Sen. Floor Analyses, Unfinished Business Analysis of Sen. Bill 574, as amended Aug. 21, 2026.)[3]

The author of SB 574 noted, "Artificial Intelligence and its use now permeate every industry in the U.S. Its capabilities continue to improve at an exponential rate, but it is far from perfect." So, "SB 574> protects those receiving legal services by codifying certain safeguards for the use of A.I. by attorneys and arbitrators."

KEY PROVISIONS OF SB 574

Attorney Obligations

SB 574 adds BPC 6068.1, which establishes three mandatory duties applicable to any attorney who uses generative AI to assist in the practice of law. These duties operate alongside, and do not abrogate, the attorney's existing obligations of competence and diligence.

One: An attorney may not enter confidential, personal identifying or other nonpublic information into a generative AI system unless access to that information is restricted to the attorney and persons authorized by the attorney under obligations to protect its confidentiality. The statute enumerates the categories of protected information: driver's license numbers, dates of birth, Social Security numbers, National Crime Information and Criminal Identification and Information numbers, addresses and phone numbers of parties, victims, witnesses and court personnel, medical or psychiatric information, financial information, account numbers and any other content sealed by court order or deemed confidential by court rule or statute. The prohibition applies to public generative AI systems for which the attorney cannot control who has access to the information entered.

Two: An attorney must take reasonable steps to verify the accuracy of all generative AI outputs, including case and statutory citations, and must correct any erroneous or hallucinated output in any material the attorney uses.

Three: An attorney must disclose the use of generative AI to the court for all documents submitted to the court. Also, an attorney must consider whether to disclose AI use when it is used to create content provided to the public.

In conjunction with BPC 6068.1, SB 574 amends CCP 128.7 to add a new paragraph specifically prohibiting any brief, pleading, motion or other paper filed in any court from containing citations that the responsible attorney has not personally verified, including citations generated by AI. This requirement is codified as part of an existing requirement attorneys must make on presenting papers to the court. It is enforceable through the existing sanctions framework of CCP 128.7, which permits courts to impose monetary and nonmonetary sanctions after notice and an opportunity to respond. Law firms can be held jointly responsible for violations by their partners, associates and employees.

Arbitrator Obligations and Regulation

SB 574 adds CCP 1282.1, which establishes two categorical prohibitions applicable to arbitrators, alongside a preservation of the arbitrator's existing duties of neutrality, competence and diligence.

One: An arbitrator may not delegate any part of the decision process to any generative AI tool. This prohibition is absolute and admits no exception.

Two: An arbitrator may not rely on information generated by generative AI that falls outside the record of the proceeding without first making appropriate disclosures to the parties and, as far as practical, allowing the parties to comment on its use.

SB 574 also significantly amends BPC 6173, the statute governing the state Bar's voluntary ADR certification program, to add a formal complaint and investigation procedure. Under the amended statute, the Bar or a professional organization it approves is authorized to receive, investigate and resolve complaints that a certified firm, provider or practitioner failed to comply with applicable ethical standards. All complaint proceedings must occur in private and be kept confidential. A party that submits a complaint is deemed to have consented to production of materials for which that party is the sole privilege holder.

ANALYSIS OF THE CHANGES

SB 574 is a significant development for California attorneys and practitioners in the workers' compensation system and across all practice areas. By codifying and expanding existing court rules on the use of AI, the Legislature has made clear that noncompliance with AI-related obligations can be addressed through formal disciplinary channels and sanctions.

The citation verification requirement under BPC 6068.1 and CCP 128.7 must be implemented immediately. The rule is unambiguous: Every citation in every filed paper must be personally verified by the responsible attorney, without exception. Even prior to SB 574, the courts sanctioned attorneys for filing documents with the court that included inaccurate or fabricated citations. Workers' compensation practitioners who use AI tools to draft petitions, letters, briefs or any papers filed with the WCAB should review their verification practices immediately.

The attorney data-entry prohibition under BPC 6068.1 also warrants immediate attention. Many widely used generative AI platforms do not restrict access to the information entered by users, and such information may be used to train models or reviewed by platform personnel. Entering case facts, medical records or client identifying information into such a system would violate the new statutory duty. It also could have implications for the attorney-client privilege and attorney work product, because disclosure of privileged information to a public AI platform may constitute a voluntary waiver of the privilege under existing law, independent of any SB 574 violation. Attorneys who have adopted AI tools in their practices should review the terms of service and data policies of those tools to determine whether they qualify as restricted-access systems under the statute, and should update their client communications and intake procedures accordingly.

Finally, BPC 6068.1 imposes a duty to disclose the use of generative AI for all documents submitted to the court. Law firms must start preparing for this requirement, which goes into effect on Jan. 1, 2027. The statute, however, does not specify the form, timing or content of that disclosure. In addition, the statute does not address how much AI input is required before the disclosure is made. For example, what if an attorney uses AI to proofread a petition? What if an attorney uses AI to check a petition but does not incorporate any changes? Such questions will be developed through court rules, state Bar guidance and, in all likelihood, future case law.

Sullivan on Comp Free Trial Offer

As for arbitrators, the prohibition on delegating decision authority to AI is absolute. The Legislature has drawn a clear line — arbitrators may not delegate any part of their decision-making process to any generative AI tool. For practitioners who represent clients in arbitration, including workers' compensation cases resolved through private arbitration, the prohibition reinforces the expectation that a human decision-maker is ultimately responsible for the award. In addition, the new ADR complaint procedure expands accountability mechanisms for certified arbitration providers in California.

For further discussion on attorney professional responsibility and obligations in the practice of workers' compensation law, see Sullivan on Comp Section 15.71 Legal Representation Before Workers' Compensation Appeals Board.

  1. See https://www.gov.ca.gov/2026/09/30/californias-nation-leading-ai-framework-just-got-stronger-governor-newsom-signs-more-first-in-the-nation-worker-protections-and-more/.
  2. https://courts.ca.gov/cms/rules/index/standards/Standard10_80.
  3. Available at https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billAnalysisClient.xhtml?bill_id=202520260SB574.